Salifert Flatworm Exit
Reviews
flat worm exit works. almost
by
THOMAS AMICK
Great
Posted: 5/29/2013 from DOYLESTOWN, PA UNITED STATES
4.0
5
Experience Level:
Intermediate
Comments:
Killed almost all flat worm and followed directions. Wrasse wasnt eating anything. A few still survive so I'll use again in a week and see. Maybe they a like ich that cat be killed in certain stages of life. It kills worm instantly and just follow directions. All livestock corals and amphipods still alive abd didnt even notice. The water change and vacuuming was more stressful!
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
ALTERNATE USES
by
JUSTIN SALVATO
Excellent!
Posted: 8/8/2012 from SICKLERVILLE, NJ UNITED STATES
5.0
5
Experience Level:
Intermediate
Comments:
OK,
We ordered this to deal with a few flatworms in my 90 before they became a problem. I also was fighting zoanthid eating nudibranches in my nano for some time, losing frag after frag of really hot zoanthids, I was ready to give up. While researching I came across someone stating that this product was highly toxic to nudibranches, so I decided to give it a try. Dosed the 90 and saw about 5-10 flatworms floating dead in the tank. Dosed the nano, and sure enough, caught a view of a nudibranch withering up and dying. I took such joy in it. We dosed my brothers two frag tanks, a 70 and a 20 where we had previously spotted a few nudis. My brother was actually able to pick one off, put it in a 1 drop to 1 gallon mix of flatworm exit, and sure enough, dead nudi. We have suffered NO ill effects. All tank critters seem unaffected and healthy, even my fan worms and feather duster are ok. No effect on copepods or mysis as others have suggested. Salifert really needs to market this as nudibranch erradication as well. Very happy with the product. More than a week later, I have zoanthid colonies bouncing back that looked dead and gone previously. To the mad scientists at Salifert, we salute you.
2 of 2 People found this review helpful, did you?
Yes
No
Does not work.
by
JERRY SEARCH
Unsatisfactory
Posted: 5/2/2012 from Salt Lake City, UT UNITED STAT
0.5
5
Experience Level:
Expert
Comments:
I'm sorry, but this stuff did NOT work. I have a 40 gallon refugium infested with flatworms. I tried Flatworm Exit 6 months ago, but I think I accidentally re-infected the aquarium. So this time I tried a new bottle. After the recommended dosage, many flatworms did die, but not all of them. After removing the remaining chemical, and the toxins that would have been released, I noticed that there were still many, dozens in fact. This time I used a triple dose, almost the whole bottle. After about 8 hours, the little buggers are still there. So now I will resort to drastic measures...
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Great, but follow instructions
by
JOEL CLARK
Excellent!
Posted: 11/27/2011 from Parkville, MO UNITED STATES
5.0
5
Experience Level:
Expert
Comments:
This product does a number on flatworms, but you must siphon out as many FW as you can, filter with carbon after use and do a large water change. You need to follow up in about 5-7 days with another treatment to get all the eggs that are not affected with the first treatment. If you follow directions and treat at least twice, it should do the trick.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
There is nothing else
by
MARK S ACKER
Excellent!
Posted: 11/25/2011 from AUSTIN, TX UNITED STATES
5.0
5
Experience Level:
Intermediate
Comments:
I have used several products in the past to treat flatworms, but this is the best by a mile. One treatment in a 210G and the worms were gone. Unlike other products, I did not have to up the dosage, nor did I have to re-treat. One and done! My mushrooms are extremely happy now! I love it when I can find one product that I know is going to work for whatever the situation it. For flatworms, this is IT!
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Great Stuff!
by
NATHAN LAIDLAW
Excellent!
Posted: 11/21/2011 from PAYSON, UT UNITED STATES
4.5
5
Experience Level:
Expert
Comments:
Worked great, easy instructions. A capfull to my 72 gal system functioned like a charm, killed my acro eating flatworms and a few red/brown planaria I did not know I had. No adverse side effects (very few flatworms vs tank volume).
Did not erradicate all flatworms (99% gone), will have to treat a second time (and to catch any new hatchings of egg sacks). This was expected, have used product in past and needed to treat twice then as well.
Follow all instructions--if you do not siphon out all flatworms you can get to, it can crash your tank when they die and spew toxins into the water.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Salifert Flatworm Exit
by
J ERIC MUSSELWHITE
Average
Posted: 8/15/2011 from SALISBURY, NC UNITED STATES
3.0
5
Experience Level:
Beginner
Comments:
It worked exactly like the ads I read said, Be sure to follow the directions and use plenty of carbon to to remove toxins released from dead flatworms... I didn't realize how many were in my tank. I used it a second time after a week to get any left.
2 of 3 People found this review helpful, did you?
Yes
No
KILLER MEDS!
by
the dude
Great
Posted: 1/31/2011 from Beautiful Blue Ridge Country
4.0
5
Experience Level:
Intermediate
Comments:
Flatworn Exit works as described! I had a huge infextation of those little creatures, and I followed the directions & they are gone!
1 of 1 People found this review helpful, did you?
Yes
No
Some always survive ...
by
sg
Below Average
Posted: 9/25/2010 from BALTIMORE, MD UNITED STATES
2.0
5
Experience Level:
Intermediate
Comments:
It does a good job of killing them, but a few always survive and they're back. I'll have to keep using it ....
1 of 1 People found this review helpful, did you?
Yes
No
Throwing money away....
by
whowadat
Unsatisfactory
Posted: 9/10/2010 from Missouri
1.0
5
Experience Level:
Intermediate
Comments:
I've used over 6 boxes of this to get rid of flatworms and they're back stronger than ever. Trust me when I say over the course of six boxes I followed directions to a T....my infestation was never really bad, I just wanted them out of my frag tank. I never lost a fish although I did have dozens of Acro frags die during treatment - that could of been caused by God knows what however...STRESS probably. It doesn't matter the dose, these little b@stards keep coming back! I was told by LFS that this stuff doesn't kill flatworm eggs ??? Supposedly it kills zoa eating nudis requiring a second dose 4 days later to kill eggs, but the directions don't mention a single thing about this product not killing flatworm eggs. (I don't know if flatworms even have eggs) I'm writing the company asking for a refund of the 140.00 dollars plus I wasted on this stuff....the only thing that truly EXITED was my money right out of my wallet.The best way to get rid of flatworms....DON'T GET 'EM IN THE FIRST PLACE!
1 of 8 People found this review helpful, did you?
Yes
No